★★★★★
Come Back As Rain begins exactly as you'd expect a Good Old War record to begin - an ambient, folk-tinged guitar lick prances around for half a minute before giving way to the dulcet vocal melodies of Keith Goodwin, Tim Arnold, and Dan Schwartzman. Just like that and Philadelphia's heralded indie-folk trio are off to the races with their much-anticipated follow up to 2010's self-titled LP...
- www.sputnikmusic.com
2012-04-12
★★★★★
Summary: On their third studio release, the Good Old War opt to walk straight down the middle, completely obscuring themselves in the process. 4 of 4 thought this review was well written It has become increasingly possible to posit that the term "indie music" has completely lost its meaning in this day and age...
- www.sputnikmusic.com
2012-04-12
★★★★★
Summary: On their third studio release, the Good Old War opt to walk straight down the middle, completely obscuring themselves in the process. 5 of 5 thought this review was well written It has become increasingly possible to posit that the term "indie music" has completely lost its meaning in this day and age...
- www.sputnikmusic.com
2012-03-06
★★★★★
The impression that listening to a Good Old War song leaves on me is not one that is commonly felt; it's not that I'm listening to insanely catchy music or absurdly talented musicians, but it's that I'm listening to catchy music written by talented musicians that is so damn refreshing compared to the norm. And that isn't a knock against whatever else I'm listening to as much as it is a tip-of-the-hat to the three amigos (Keith Goodwin, Tim Arnold, Daniel Schwartz) that make up Good Old War...
- absolutepunk.net
2012-03-06
★★★★★
The success of Britain's Mumford & Sons has given hope to countless other acoustic pop outfits the world over, and this third full-length release from Good Old War is perfectly in tune with folk music's current mainstream resurgence. However, what this trio from Philadelphia, PA are offering, in spite of their rough-hewn hipster image, is nothing new and can be traced back to Barenaked Ladies through Simon & Garfunkel, Crosby, Stills & Nash and even the Kingston Trio...
- exclaim.ca
2012-03-06
★★★★★
Come Back As Rain begins exactly as you'd expect a Good Old War record to begin - an ambient, folk-tinged guitar lick prances around for half a minute before giving way to the dulcet vocal melodies of Keith Goodwin, Tim Arnold, and Dan Schwartzman. Just like that and Philadelphia's heralded indie-folk trio are off to the races with their much-anticipated follow up to 2010's self-titled LP...
- www.sputnikmusic.com
2012-03-06
★★★★★
There's a pure simplicity to Good Old War's music that's hard to resist. The band builds its lovely acoustic-based music out of gorgeous harmonies, gently-played guitars and light percussion. The opening track offers a perfect example of what Good Old War does so well. "Over and Over" serves up airy vocals, strummy acoustic guitars and the pattering of percussions...
- www.americansongwriter.com
2012-03-06
★★★★★
The appeal of Good Old War stems from their simplicity. So when their debut album, Only Way To Be Alone was released, it was received warmly by fans and critics alike. The band functions in a stripped down setting with acoustic guitars or clean electric guitar tones. Rather than scorching guitar leads or face melting solos in the forefront, the band uses their capoed chords and gentle guitar lines to win the audience over...
- www.reviewrinserepeat.com
2010-12-14
★★★★★
Picture yourself in a log cabin, snow outside, hot cuppa in your paws and a roaring fire at your feet. Not a care in the world, this is where 'One Way To Be Alone' transports you. Beautiful harmonious vocals, charming guitar notes and well driven drumming are endless in this record. The three way harmonies play with your emotions and tickle at the essence of life. Some may describe this music as "Camp-fire" or "Camping" music, it certainly sets the scene...
- hangout.altsounds.com
2010-11-02