★★★★★
Badda boom. Okay, it's not a bomb, per se. But it's hard to get all O Holy Night over four guys who'd bang Frosty, Rudolph and all of Santa's elves if you took your eyes off them for five seconds. The production and orchestration are waaaay over the top, exposing the failure of form over function, not that this product from Simon Cowell - who, if he hasn't stolen Christmas yet, is doubtless in the process of trying - would have any problem with that.
- www.hour.ca
2010-11-02
★★★★★
The members of this multinational, Simon Cowell-assembled quartet seemengineered for maximum unhipness: Their smooth, operatic vocals andanonymously chiseled looks wouldn't offend the most reservedgreat-grandmother. The new string-laden weepers on Il Divo's thirdstudio CD, Siempre, make pleasant background music, and an Italian-language MoodyBlues cover (one of three retooled oldies) captures some of theoriginal's melodramatic verve...
- ew.com
2009-06-12
★★★★★
The demand for an operatic rendition of Eric Carmen's "All by Myself" isfinally answered with Il Divo's Ancora, the multiplatinum multicultiquartet's third platter of classical classics, treacly originals, andpop covers. Formed by American Idol's Simon Cowell, Il Divo specializein watered-down, pop-addled opera gallantry, a highly suspect genre wedub "Oprah...
- ew.com
2009-06-12
★★★★★
Simon Cowell's "man band" creation Il Divo bring their perfect hair and immaculate throats into the crowded holiday genre with the creatively titled Christmas Collection, a heavily decorated box of yuletide favorites that dutifully showcases each tenor's captivating voice...
- music.aol.com
2008-08-27